Clavicle Fractures

Incidence

  • 4% of all fractures
  • 35% of fractures of shoulder region
  • Bimodal Distribution
    • second/third
      • males
      • violent or high-energy injuries (e.g., bicycle, motor vehicle accidents, sports injuries).
      • direct trauma to the point of the shoulder causes the compressed clavicle to fail
    • sixth/seventh decades of life
      • osteoporotic bones
      • result of simple falls from a standing height onto an outstretched hand.

Anatomy

  • S-shaped
  • Medial portion is cylindrical
  • Lateral portion is relatively flat
  • Medullary canal is small due to thick cortical bone
  • Ligaments:
    • Medial (very strong)
      • sternoclavicular, costoclavicular, and interclavicular ligaments
    • Lateral
      • acromioclavicular and the two coracoclavicular ligaments, the conoid and the trapezoid
  • Muscles attached to osseous surface
    • platysma, sternocleidomastoid, pectoralis major, subclavius, deltoid, and trapezius.
  • The clavicle shields important underlying neurovascular structures
    • brachial plexus, subclavian vessels
    • only bone that connects the upper limb to the axial skeleton

Classification

Allman

GroupDescription 
Imiddle third fractures85%
IIlateral third fractures10%
IIImedial third fractures5%
Allman Classification of Clavicle Fractures
  • Middle third fractures: weakest point of the clavicle lies at the transition region between the curves where the bone is found to be thinnest and lacks any muscular or ligamentous support

Neer divided Allman’s group II (lateral third)

Type Description
Icoracoclavicular ligaments intact, attached to medial segment
IIcoracoclavicular ligaments detached from the medial segment but trapezoid intact to distal segment
IIAboth the conoid & trapezoid remain attached to the distal segment
IIBthe conoid is torn
IIIintraarticular extension into the acromioclavicular joint
Neer’s Classification of Lateral Third Clavicular Fractures

Craig Classification

Group Description
1Fracture of the Middle Third
2Fracture of the Distal Third
 Type Iminimal displacement (interligamentous)
Type IIdisplaced secondary to fracture line medial to the coracoclavicular ligaments
A – conoid & trapezoid attached
B – conoid torn, trapezoid attached
Type IIIfractures of the articular surface
Type IVperiosteal sleeve fracture (children)
Type Vcomminuted with ligaments attached neither proximally nor distally, but to an inferior comminuted fragment
3Fracture of the Proximal Third
 Type Iminimal displacement
Type IIdisplaced (ligaments ruptured)
Type IIIintraarticular
Type IVepiphyseal separation (children & young adults)
Type Vcommunited
Craig Classification of Clavicle Fractures

Treatment

Tradition view

  • most fractures can be treated nonoperative because of high rates of union and low chance of complations
  • True for children and adolescent, ? Not true for adults and elderly
    • Nonunion / malunion
    • pain, deformity, weakness, neurovascular symptoms, decreased function

Nonoperative

  • Options
    • Broad arm sling
    • Figure of eight brace
  • Indications
    • majority of fractures
      • medial third fractures
      • middle third fractures
      • distal third types I, IV, V

Operative

  • ORIF
    • Indications
      • DIsplacemnt / shortening >15 – 20 mm
      • Distal type II (a and b)
      • open fractures;
      • associated vascular injury;
      • progressive neurological deficits;
      • gross displacement with skin tenting that will likely lead to skin breakdown;
      • significant medialization of the shoulder girdle;
      • torn coracoclavicular ligaments with distal fracture;
      • ipsilateral fractures of the clavicle and scapula (floating shoulder);
      • multiply injured patients;
      • bilateral clavicular fractures;
      • complex, ipsilateral, upper-extremity fracture.
    • Contraindications
      • compromised soft tissue,
      • active infection at or near the operative site,
      • an unreliable or noncompliant patient
  • Closed treatment with late excision arthroplasty
    • Indications
      • Distal third Type III
  • Lateral Fractures
    • Treatment controversial
    • Operative methods
      • ORIF clavicle (may not have enough screw purchase is distal segment)
      • Bridge AC joint with wires or plates
      • Fixation to coracoid (temporary coracoclavicular screw, loop of Dacron tape)

References