Definition
- Degenerative, chronic arthropathy characterized by cartilage loss, new bone formation at joint margins & capsular fibrosis
Aetiology
Primary & Secondary
- Primary
- Idiopathic
- Secondary
- Traumatic
- Fracture
- Meniscectomy
- Limb Malalignment
- Instability
- Hypermobility
- Developmental/ Dysplasia
- MED
- DDH
- Perthes
- SUFE
- Metabolic
- CPPD deposition
- Haemochromatosis
- Ochronosis
- Inflammatory
- RA/ AS
- Gout/ CPPD
- Septic Arthritis
- Neuropathic
- Vascular
- AVN
- Endocrine
- Acromegaly
- Ochronosis
- Traumatic
Two Categories of Cause
- 1. Abnormal forces on normal cartilage
- 2. Normal forces on abnormal cartilage
- Ie. the cartilage fatigue threshold is overcome
- Abnormal Forces
- Force = Load/ Unit area
- Increased Load
- Both magnitude & frequency
- Eg. Obese
- Decreased Contact Area
- Stress exceeds local threshold
- Age
- More stiff & less strong & elastic
- Difference from Osteoarthritis poorly defined
- Hypocellular
- Decreased water (cf. Osteoarthritis with damaged cartilage imbibing water)
- Increased Stiffness
- CPP & HA deposition
- Increased Softness
- Chronic Inflammation
- Age
Risk Factors
- Obesity
- Especially Knee > Hip > Hand
- 7x risk
- Reason
- Animal studies high fat diet » Osteoarthritis
- ? Metabolic & mechanical reason
- Heredity
- Increased polyarthritic Osteoarthritis in families
- ? Mutation Type II procollagen
- Trauma
- Cartilage injury at time of trauma
- Malunion resulting in abnormal force vectors
- Occupational
- ? Repetitive use
- Sport
- Throwing athletes – elbow
Pathogenesis
- Primarily mechanical rather than inflammatory
- Failure of cartilage’s attempt at repair
- Articular Cartilage
- Key events are in the cartilage
- Collagen network damaged & disorganized
- Loss of proteoglycan which leach from matrix
- Synthesis increases, but can’t keep up
- Decreased Chondroitin Sulfate : Keratin Sulfate ratio
- Decreased CS
- Increased KS
- Increase water
- Decreased Chondroitin Sulfate : Keratin Sulfate ratio
- As a result of above the water content ↑ cartilage swells due to
- Exposed collagen
- Unwound PG
- The stiff cartilage has ↓ lubrication ability
- Due to ↑ permeability
- Weeping
- Elastohydrodynamic
- Poor lubrication results in development of fissures on surface
- IL1 released from synovium & chondrocytes
- IL1 important mediator of metalloproteinases
- Collagenase > Collagen
- Stromelysin > PG
- Gelatinase
- Subchondral Bone
- Sclerosis
- Increase force transmitted to bone
- Wolff’s law
- Result is ↑ mechanical strain on overlying cartilage
- Precipitates cartilage degeneration
- Wolff’s law
- Cysts
- ? Due to
- Stress fractures
- Focal AVN
- Synovial fluid pump through cracks
- Osteophytes
- ? Result of pizeoelectric forces from abnormal stress
- ? Intramembranous ossification & endochondral
- Increased surface area of joint
Pathology
- Cardinal features are
- Cartilage disintegration
- Subchondral sclerosis
- Subchondral cysts
- Osteophyte formation
- Capsular fibrosis
- Cartilage Destruction
- Macroscopic
- At most heavily loaded part
- Softened & fibrillated
- Fibrillation propagated as fissures to subchondral bone
- Fragments separate
- Become loose bodies which can ↑ in size
- Digested
- Cartilage lost
- Bone exposed & eburnated
- Microscopic
- Vertical clefts in surface
- Superficial chondrocyte loss
- Increased cellularity with clusters of chondrocytes
- Duplication & irregularity of tidemark
- Subchondral Plate Sclerosis
- Dense & thickened
- Marked osteoblastic activity
- Increased vascularity
- Macroscopic
- Subchondral Cyst Formation
- Usually near maximum cartilage loss
- May extend into metaphysis
- Margins sclerotic
- Filled with thick gelatinous material
- Osteophyte formation
- Bone at margins of joint
- Cortex thickened & sclerotic
- Prominent cement lines
- Parallel to joint surface
- Covered in hyaline cartilage
- Capsular Fibrosis
- Capsule markedly thickened
- May be adherent
- Hyalinization & amyloid
- Synovial Thickening
- Debris in synovial fluid incites phagocytosis by synovial cells
- Breakdown products evoke mild inflammatory response
- Slightly thick membrane
Epidemiology
Prevalence
- Rises steeply with age
- 15% at 40
- 75% at 70
- > 50% have symptoms
Clinical Features
- Usually middle age
- Atraumatic onset
Symptoms
- Pain
- Usual presentation
- Insidious onset
- Slow worsening
- May be ill-defined or referred
- Initially mechanical
- Graduate to constant
- Then night pain develops
- Often worst 1st few steps
- Stiffness
- Occurs after inactivity
- Becomes constant
- AM stiffness not as prominent as RA
- Swelling
- Intermittent from effusion
- Continuous due to capsular thickening or osteophytes
- Deformity
- From joint instability
- Disability
- Inability to perform ADL
Signs
- Swelling
- Effusion
- Capsular / Synovial thickening
- Osteophytes
- Deformity
- Muscle wasting
- Tenderness
- Restricted ROM
- Crepitus
- Instability
Grade | Description |
---|---|
I | softening & swelling of cartilage |
II | fragmentation & fissuring in area > 1.3cm |
III | as grade 2 but area > 1.3cm |
IV | erosion of cartilage down to bone |
Patterns
Monoarticular or Pauciarticular Osteoarthritis
- Pain & dysfunction in 1 or 2 of the large weight bearing joints
- Two subgroups
- Secondary Osteoarthritis
- Osteoarthritis single joint from previous problem
- Most common is knee from meniscectomy
- Primary Hip Osteoarthritis
- Usually early in male
- Maybe due to mild dysplasia
- Secondary Osteoarthritis
Polyarticular Osteoarthritis
- Usually middle-aged woman
- Pain, swelling & stiffness in fingers
- Characteristic knobbly appearance of IPJ
- From osteophytes & soft tissue swelling
- Heberden’s Nodes – DIP joints
- Bouchard’s Nodes – PIP joints
- From osteophytes & soft tissue swelling
- Often affects knees
- Medial & PFJ compartments
- May also affect
- Base of thumb
- MTPJ of hallux
- Facet Joints
Rapidly Destructive Osteoarthritis
- Rapidly progressive loss of joint space
- Usually affects hip
Investigations
Xrays
- Asymmetric narrowing of joint space
- Subchondral sclerosis
- Subchondral cysts
- Osteophytes
- ± Evidence of previous disorders
Bone Scan
- Increased activity in subchondral region
- Reflects ↑ vascularity & new bone formation
Differential Diagnosis
- DISH
- AVN
- CPPD
- HA
- RA
- Psoriatic arthritis
Management
- Early
- Pain relief
- Analgesics
- NSAID
- Local heat
- Rest
- Modify activities
- Rest during flares
- Physiotherapy
- Maintain ROM
- Maintain power
- Load reduction
- Weight loss
- Walking stick
- Avoid of unnecessary stress
- Brace
- Intermediate
- Realignment osteotomy
- A/S washout
- SynVisc (hyaluronic acid) ?
- Late
- Arthrodesis
- Arthroplasty
Controversies
- Glucosamine & Chondroitin Sulfate
- Animal trials
- suggest possible cartilage protective role
- Human clinical trials
- Nearly all have financial backing from drug companies
- Show variable benefit with respect to pain & function
- Probably not alter natural history
- Probably no harm (certainly less harmful than NSAID) & may be beneficial
- Animal trials